Skip to main content

Macaroni Men and Yankee Doodles



The Spirit of '76 (original title Yankee Doodle)
by Archibald Willard, painted in the late 1800s


November is a month that here in the United States is defined by food, culminating in a huge Thanksgiving Day feast. It's also the month we honor our military veterans. So I'm going to focus on both food and patriotism - especially an Italian pasta product that became synonymous with a controversial English fashion and developed uniquely American associations.

"The Macaroni"- 1773
During the 18th century, it was all the rage for young men of the English nobility to take a trip through Europe to soak up its art and culture. It was called the Grand Tour.

In Italy, these privileged lads discovered a pasta dish far removed from their usual British fare. It was called maccaroni, and they raved about it when they got back home. The travelers became known as the Macaroni Club, though there is no evidence an actual club ever existed.

But it wasn't their love of pasta recipes that made the club members distinctive. Along with foreign food, these young aristocrats adopted a style of dress and behavior that was vastly different than the norm.


'What is this my Son Tom?"- 1774
Scorning the conservative tailoring and colors that most British men favored, these young men wore tight-fitting suits made of colorful silk, velvet, and gold or silver lamé, adorned with sequins and bows. They wore make-up and perfume, carried parasols and spoke with high-pitched accents. They also spent lavishly on other fancy accessories, like walking sticks, spyglasses, snuff boxes and shoe buckles.

Another must-have fashion feature was a towering, powdered wig, topped with an absurdly small hat, called a "macaroni," which supposedly could be removed with the tip of a sword.

With their outlandish clothing and extreme affectations, the Macaroni Men seemed like a strange new species, neither male nor female, to their stolid countrymen. With undeniably ambiguous sexuality, the Macaronis became a target of homophobic ridicule and condemnation. That was no small matter, because at that time homosexuality was a crime punishable by death.

Beau Brummell
And while the term "macaroni" may seem the same as “dandy" to our ears, the two styles of male dress were actually very different. Under the influence of noted Regency dandy Beau Brummell, dandyism was viewed as a restrained, masculine style. Today's male fashions still owe a lot to the style Brummell championed 200 years ago.

But the Macaronis weren’t fazed by criticism or caricature. And now, looking back over the centuries, their style could be considered an early forerunner to today’s transgender fashions.

The fad for this painted, foppish style reached a peak in the 1770s, which was the same time the British were having a spot of trouble with their American colonies. And that's where the song “Yankee Doodle Dandy” comes in.

It's an old melody, possibly a Dutch harvest song. The music itself is much older than any lyrics. It's a tune that goes back to at least to 15th-century Holland if not medieval times.

During the French and Indian War, British soldiers created a new set of lyrics to mock the Americans, and "Yankee Doodle Dandy" was born.

Here are a few of the many, many verses of the song that we sing today. (Note: Captain Gooding is probably a generic name for an officer in the Continental Army. And as for hasty pudding, it's a bowl of mush, made from wheat or cornmeal.)

Yankee Doodle went to town
A-riding on a pony,
Stuck a feather in his cap
And called it Macaroni


[Chorus]

Yankee Doodle keep it up,
Yankee Doodle dandy
Mind the music and the step,
And with the girls be handy.

Father and I went down to camp,
Along with Captain Gooding,
And there we saw the men and boys
As thick as hasty pudding.


That's one popular version of the song. But it's not like the lyrics are set in stone. Oh, wait a minute – they are!




And here's how some of the slurs in the song break down:
  • First of all, "Yankee" is likely a corruption of "Janke" an old Dutch nickname for "John" ("Jan"). The British must have thought using this Dutch name was either funny or a slam against the American colonists, or both.
  • "Doodle" at that time was another word for "fool" (think "doofus").
  • The "pony" mentioned in the song shows that this doodle couldn't even afford a horse – a more manly ride.
  • Finally, since he wanted to be called a Macaroni, a stereotype widely seen as effeminate and even gay, the Brits were actually calling the Yankees gay and assuming that they wouldn't be able to put up much of a fight.
Altogether, the song is the type of insult you'd expect from middle-school bullies on a playground.

There's a snobbish aspect to the satiric ditty as well. Macaronis were members of the British nobility and the stupid doodle thought it was enough to "stick a feather in his cap" to be accepted into that class.

But during the American Revolution, the rebels turned the tables. They embraced the song and used it to taunt their enemy. Captured British soldiers complained that they were forced to sing the song over and over again as a punishment. The captive redcoats got quite sick of it, and probably wished they'd never made those lyrics up in the first place.

Today Americans call themselves Yankee Doodle Dandies with pride. “Yankee Doodle” is the state song of Connecticut, one of the 13 rebel colonies. And then there's the New York Yankees, a professional baseball team.

So, Yankee Doodle lives on, but today most people think of pasta not people when they hear the word “macaroni."

However, there are some signs that Macaronis are becoming fashionable once again, minus the stigma they had centuries ago. Transgender models are making an impact on fashion runways around the world, and companies like Morphe and others promote cosmetics for the LBGTQ community. The taboo against men using beauty products and wearing makeup is rapidly fading.

There's even a modern-day Macaroni who's adopted the 18th-century term. Mark Thawin is a Thai hairstylist who uses the handle "macaroniii" for his Instagram account, where he regularly posts stylish photos of himself. He currently has over 24,000 followers.

However, in the US the term "macaroni" still has patriotic connotations, even though most of us have forgotten its original meaning.

Caroline with her dad in 1963
And that's because of the widespread popularity of "Yankee Doodle."

In the 1960s, President John F. Kennedy gave his daughter Caroline a pony that the Kennedys named Macaroni in honor of the Revolutionary ballad.

And speaking of the 20th century, I have to mention the famous 1904 George M. Cohan song, "(I'm a) Yankee Doodle Dandy."

Cohan's creation made movie history when James Cagney performed it with his signature tap-dancing strut in the 1942 movie Yankee Doodle Dandy.

Here's a brief clip:




All things considered, macaroni is a pretty patriotic dish. Maybe it should be a Thanksgiving staple, right up there with turkey and cranberry sauce.

And don't forget the feather! A turkey feather will do. 



Vintage postcard from Dave /Flickr.com



Sources for this post include:

Peter MacNeil, Pretty Gentlemen: Macaroni Men and the Eighteenth-Century Fashion World, Yale University Press, New Haven and London, 2018

David Segal, ”That Diss Song Known as ‘Yankee Doodle’” The New York Times, July 1, 2017

Rictor Norton, "The Macaroni Club: Homosexual Scandals in 1772", Homosexuality in Eighteenth-Century England: A Sourcebook, December 19, 2004, updated June 11, 2005, updated June 13, 2017


~~

Images courtesy of Wikimedia Commons

Comments

  1. I had no idea that James Cagney could really dance! I've always thought of him as a gangster character.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for your comment! Cagney was very versatile - he grew up in vaudeville, and he could dance and sing and crack jokes with the best of them. But in the movies he could portray truly terrible bad guys. He has a famous scene in 1931's The Public Enemy where his character (a gangster) smashes half a grapefruit into his girlfriend's face. It was his breakthrough role!

      Delete
  2. Thanks for your blog post. I thought it was very infomative and entertaining! When I watched the video clip with Jimmy Cagney dancing up the wall, it reminded me of Penelope and Athena! I saw both bunnies do the same thing when they were in their little outdoor pen! Haha!!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I would've loved to see that! Maybe they were born to dance! Thanks for the comment and the image of the bunnies dancing in their pen.

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Cato Street Conspiracy

Conspiracy and treason go hand in hand. Throughout history, conspirators have huddled in back rooms and dark corners in secret, concocting schemes that are both dangerous and illegal. So it’s no surprise that their plans often spiral out of control and end in disaster. 
A good example of a conspiracy plot gone wrong happened during the Regency. It’s been dubbed the Cato Street Conspiracy because of where the conspirators were caught. This is a tale that, according to historian J.B. Priestley (author of The Prince of Pleasure and his Regency) “begins in absurdity and ends in horror.”
The year was 1820. Though the Napoleonic Wars were over, Britain had paid a heavy price for its victory against the French. The costs of the war had strained the country’s economy. The working classes were hit hard by periods of famine, rising food prices due to the Corn Laws, and high unemployment, the latter driven by soldiers returning from the battlefields of Europe and looking for work. And of course, t…

The end of the Holy Roman Empire, or what happens when the Empire doesn't strike back

This is the way the world ends Not with a bang but a whimper
T.S. Eliot wasn't actually describing the dissolution of the Holy Roman Empire when he wrote those words in his poem, “The Hollow Men.” Nonetheless, his words are an extremely apt way to describe the end of the Holy Roman Empire, which ended quietly with a stroke of a pen exactly 212 years ago in August of 1806. That’s when the last emperor decided it was his duty to abdicate, letting the ancient dominion under his protection dissolve rather than allow Napoleon to usurp the role of Holy Roman Emperor and everything that came with it. By that August the end of the empire had become inevitable. Napoleon’s victory over Russia and Austria at the Battle of Austerlitz in December of 1805 and his formation of the Confederation of the Rhine the following July (after he convinced 16 German princes to renounce their allegiance to the Holy Roman Empire and join him) were fatal blows. Throughout its thousand-year history, the Empire e…

At the drop of a hat: a history of headgear

“Cock your hat – angles are attitudes,” said Frank Sinatra. While I would never disagree with Ol’ Blue Eyes, because I believe that a hat set at a rakish angle makes a statement in any era, I’d take it a step further. Sometimes the hat itself speaks volumes, all by itself, no matter how it sits on someone's head.
Cast your mind back to the Women’s March in Washington, D.C., in January of 2017. The hundreds of thousands of pink knitted or crocheted hats atop the heads of a sea of protestors made an unforgettable sight and sent a clear visual message concerning the marchers' support of human rights, along with their criticism of the newly inaugurated President Trump.
Likewise, a red mesh trucker hat emblazoned with the slogan “Make America Great Again” has become an unmistakable badge of a Trump supporter.
And hats were especially important during the French Revolution, just prior to our Regency era. During that turbulent time a poor unfortunate who wasn’t wearing a hat associated …